The Criminalization of Teen Sex
Derek “The Fallen One” Logue
August 29, 2008, Update March 18, 2010
In Iowa, a sixteen-year-old boy meets another teen and they date and have sex; turns out the girl was only
13, and the teen finds himself on a sex offender registry [1]. In Oregon, two thirteen year old boys faced 10
years and life on the sex offender registry for participating in “slap butt day,” a common form of horseplay
at the school; the district had prosecuted other children for sexual harassment in similar cases [2]. In
Florida, two teens were convicted of child porn for taking racy pictures of themselves [3]. The Utah
Supreme Court recently ruled on a case in which a 13 year old girl was charged as both victim of a sex
crime and a perpetrator for having consensual sex with her 12-year-old boyfriend [4]. These cases are
merely the tip of the ice burg in a society obsessed with punishing sex offenders.
The criminalization of teenage sexual behavior has become a disturbing trend in our predator panicked
society. We are simultaneously obsessed with sex and horrified by sex; our laws reflect this panic. For
example, we allow 12-year-olds to obtain birth control and abortions, but they cannot consent to sex [5].
Criminalizing teen sex is part of the “look tough on crime” stance which is popular in today’s society, yet
few people are educating the public about the real possibility of teens landing on sex offender registries for
irresponsible sexual behavior [6]. Legislators in Georgia failed to pass a bill mandating schools teach the
legal consequences of teen sex, though it later passed a “watered-down” version of the bill [7]. This
mentality has led to disastrous consequences, destroying the lives of many teenagers by placing them on
sex offender registries for life!
The possibility of teens landing on the registry is very real, as teens are having sex without knowledge of
the consequences. The Center for Disease Control found in one biannual survey of ninth to twelfth
graders that 45.3% of teen girls and 48% of teen boys have had sex. Furthermore, 4.2% of females and
10.4% of males had sex before age 13, and 11.2% of females and 17.5% of males had four or more sex
partners [8]. A 2002 National Survey of Family Growth found that of the teens age 15 to 19 who have
never had sexual intercourse, 24% of males and 22% of females engaged in oral sex [9]. In short, more
than half of teens have experienced sexual contact of some kind. This does not even include actions such
as taking naughty photos, butt slapping, or even some innocent actions misinterpreted as sexually
motivated conduct.
If you think your child is immune, think again. Children as young as pre-school students have faced severe
penalties for “inappropriate sexual behaviors.” The Virginia Department of Education reported in 2007,
255 elementary students were suspended for offensive sexual touching; the Maryland Department of
Education reported 166 elementary students were suspended for sexual harassment. These suspensions
add a permanent mark on the child’s school records [10]. The AP recently noted from 1993 to 2004, adult
sex crimes decreased by 56% but juvenile crimes increased 40% by the same period [11]. However, what
percentage of these cases involves forcible rape or child molestation as opposed to consensual sexual
activity with peers?
In our quest to prevent sexual violence, we are willing to place marks of infamy on children as young as
four in the name of public safety, proclaiming the ironic mantra, “If it saves just one child, then the law is
worth it.” Tell me, are we willing to destroy the lives of many children to save “just one child?”
Resources
A Collection of similar stories, collected by "Sex Offender Issues," can be found here:
http://delicious.com/SOIssues/offenderchild
Other stories:
http://www.love-is-not-a-crime.com/ -- A new site dedicated to removing Romeo and Juliet offenses from
the sex offender registries!
http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=5373858&page=1 – Georgia, 17 year old girl on registry for oral
sex with 15 year old
http://womensissues.about.com/od/datingandsex/a/Romeo_and_Julie.htm -- Teen Sex laws, gay bias, and
motivated by angry parents
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=10972703 – The Genarlow Wilson case
www.changingthelaw.com -- How you can be on the sex registry just for chatting, no sex or even meeting.
Yet Mark Foley is not in prison or on a registry.
www.kxan.com/dpp/news/crime/Texas_teenage_sex_laws_under_fire -- Texas Justice; American citizen
born in Mexico facing deportation for consensual sex with another teen
http://www.abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=6029237&page=1 : Here is a news report regarding teens
who send nude pictures of themselves to their dates being arrested for dissemination of "child porn"
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9B04E1DA1531F935A25755C0A9679C8B63 -
"Prosecutors and public defenders estimate that 10 percent to 25 percent of the [New Jersey] offenders
are under 18, with many fewer under 14 and only a handful as young as 10."
STUDY OF TEENS AND "SEXTING" Dec. 2008
http://www.thenationalcampaign.org/sextech/PDF/SexTech_Summary.pdf -- Survey of Teens and Sexting
released by the National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unwanted Pregnancy and Cosmo Girl Magazine.
A few of the Key Findings:
How many teens say they have sent/posted nude or seminude pictures or video of themselves?
- 20% of teens overall
- 22% of teen girls
- 18% of teen boys
- 11% of young teen girls (ages 13-16)
How many teens are sending or posting sexually suggestive messages?
- 39% of all teens
- 37% of teen girls
- 40% of teen boys
- 48% of teens say they have received such messages
Although most teens and young adults who send sexually suggestive content are sending it to boyfriends /
girlfriends, others say they are sending such material to those they want to hook up with or to someone
they only know online.
Who are these sexually suggestive messages and images being sent to?
- 71% of teen girls and 67% of teen guys who have sent or posted sexually suggestive content say they
have sent/posted this content to a boyfriend/girlfriend.
- 21% of teen girls and 39% of teen boys say they have sent such content to someone they wanted to date
or hook up with.
- 15% of teens who have sent or posted nude/seminude images of themselves say they have done so to
someone they only knew online.
- 83% of young adult women and 75% of young adult men who have sent sexually suggestive content say
they have sent/posted such material to a boyfriend/ girlfriend.
- 21% of young adult women and 30% of young adult men who have sent/posted sexually suggestive
content have done so to someone they wanted to date or hook up with.
- 15% of young adult women and 23% of young adult men who have sent sexually suggestive material say
they have done so to someone they only knew online.
Addendum
Derek “The Fallen One” Logue
August 29, 2008, Update March 18, 2010
In Iowa, a sixteen-year-old boy meets another teen and they date and have sex; turns out the girl was only
13, and the teen finds himself on a sex offender registry [1]. In Oregon, two thirteen year old boys faced 10
years and life on the sex offender registry for participating in “slap butt day,” a common form of horseplay
at the school; the district had prosecuted other children for sexual harassment in similar cases [2]. In
Florida, two teens were convicted of child porn for taking racy pictures of themselves [3]. The Utah
Supreme Court recently ruled on a case in which a 13 year old girl was charged as both victim of a sex
crime and a perpetrator for having consensual sex with her 12-year-old boyfriend [4]. These cases are
merely the tip of the ice burg in a society obsessed with punishing sex offenders.
The criminalization of teenage sexual behavior has become a disturbing trend in our predator panicked
society. We are simultaneously obsessed with sex and horrified by sex; our laws reflect this panic. For
example, we allow 12-year-olds to obtain birth control and abortions, but they cannot consent to sex [5].
Criminalizing teen sex is part of the “look tough on crime” stance which is popular in today’s society, yet
few people are educating the public about the real possibility of teens landing on sex offender registries for
irresponsible sexual behavior [6]. Legislators in Georgia failed to pass a bill mandating schools teach the
legal consequences of teen sex, though it later passed a “watered-down” version of the bill [7]. This
mentality has led to disastrous consequences, destroying the lives of many teenagers by placing them on
sex offender registries for life!
The possibility of teens landing on the registry is very real, as teens are having sex without knowledge of
the consequences. The Center for Disease Control found in one biannual survey of ninth to twelfth
graders that 45.3% of teen girls and 48% of teen boys have had sex. Furthermore, 4.2% of females and
10.4% of males had sex before age 13, and 11.2% of females and 17.5% of males had four or more sex
partners [8]. A 2002 National Survey of Family Growth found that of the teens age 15 to 19 who have
never had sexual intercourse, 24% of males and 22% of females engaged in oral sex [9]. In short, more
than half of teens have experienced sexual contact of some kind. This does not even include actions such
as taking naughty photos, butt slapping, or even some innocent actions misinterpreted as sexually
motivated conduct.
If you think your child is immune, think again. Children as young as pre-school students have faced severe
penalties for “inappropriate sexual behaviors.” The Virginia Department of Education reported in 2007,
255 elementary students were suspended for offensive sexual touching; the Maryland Department of
Education reported 166 elementary students were suspended for sexual harassment. These suspensions
add a permanent mark on the child’s school records [10]. The AP recently noted from 1993 to 2004, adult
sex crimes decreased by 56% but juvenile crimes increased 40% by the same period [11]. However, what
percentage of these cases involves forcible rape or child molestation as opposed to consensual sexual
activity with peers?
In our quest to prevent sexual violence, we are willing to place marks of infamy on children as young as
four in the name of public safety, proclaiming the ironic mantra, “If it saves just one child, then the law is
worth it.” Tell me, are we willing to destroy the lives of many children to save “just one child?”
Resources
- www.rickyslife.com
- Susan Goldsmith. “Unruly schoolboys or sex offenders?” The Oregonian, July 2, 2007.
- Declan McCullagh. “Police blotter: Teens prosecuted for racy photos.” CNET News, Feb. 9, 2007.
http://news.cnet.com/Police-blotter-Teens-prosecuted-for-racy-photos/2100-1030_3-6157857.html?
tag=newsmap - Pamela Mason. “Girl, 13, charged as sex offender and victim.” Salt Lake Tribune, Dec. 26, 2006,
http://www.denverpost.com/ci_4783650 - Niki Delson. “Age of Consent – Criminalizing Teen Sex.” American Chronicle, May 31, 2007. http:
//www.americanchronicle.com/articles/28524 - Shannon McCaffrey. “Many teens don’t know the law about sex.” USA Today, Oct. 29, 2007. http:
//www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2007-10-29-306192904_x.htm - Shannon McCaffrey. “Critics say teens need education on sex laws.” Savannah Morning News, Aug.
18, 2007, http://savannahnow.com/node/345973 - Center for Disease Control. “Youth Risk Behavioral Surveillance System.” 2003, http://www.cdc.
gov/mmwr/PDF/SS/SS5302.pdf - “Oral sex.” Child Trends Data Bank, 2003, http://www.childtrendsdatabank.org/indicators/95OralSex.
cfm - Brigid Schuldte. “For Little Children, Grown-up Labels as Sexual Harassers.” Washington Post, April
3, 2008. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/story/2008/04/02/ST2008040203589.html?
hpid=topnews - John “Jack” Tefler. “Obsession With Sex, Violence Impacting Our Kids.” Midland Daily News, July 1,
2007
A Collection of similar stories, collected by "Sex Offender Issues," can be found here:
http://delicious.com/SOIssues/offenderchild
Other stories:
http://www.love-is-not-a-crime.com/ -- A new site dedicated to removing Romeo and Juliet offenses from
the sex offender registries!
http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=5373858&page=1 – Georgia, 17 year old girl on registry for oral
sex with 15 year old
http://womensissues.about.com/od/datingandsex/a/Romeo_and_Julie.htm -- Teen Sex laws, gay bias, and
motivated by angry parents
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=10972703 – The Genarlow Wilson case
www.changingthelaw.com -- How you can be on the sex registry just for chatting, no sex or even meeting.
Yet Mark Foley is not in prison or on a registry.
www.kxan.com/dpp/news/crime/Texas_teenage_sex_laws_under_fire -- Texas Justice; American citizen
born in Mexico facing deportation for consensual sex with another teen
http://www.abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=6029237&page=1 : Here is a news report regarding teens
who send nude pictures of themselves to their dates being arrested for dissemination of "child porn"
http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9B04E1DA1531F935A25755C0A9679C8B63 -
"Prosecutors and public defenders estimate that 10 percent to 25 percent of the [New Jersey] offenders
are under 18, with many fewer under 14 and only a handful as young as 10."
STUDY OF TEENS AND "SEXTING" Dec. 2008
http://www.thenationalcampaign.org/sextech/PDF/SexTech_Summary.pdf -- Survey of Teens and Sexting
released by the National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unwanted Pregnancy and Cosmo Girl Magazine.
A few of the Key Findings:
How many teens say they have sent/posted nude or seminude pictures or video of themselves?
- 20% of teens overall
- 22% of teen girls
- 18% of teen boys
- 11% of young teen girls (ages 13-16)
How many teens are sending or posting sexually suggestive messages?
- 39% of all teens
- 37% of teen girls
- 40% of teen boys
- 48% of teens say they have received such messages
Although most teens and young adults who send sexually suggestive content are sending it to boyfriends /
girlfriends, others say they are sending such material to those they want to hook up with or to someone
they only know online.
Who are these sexually suggestive messages and images being sent to?
- 71% of teen girls and 67% of teen guys who have sent or posted sexually suggestive content say they
have sent/posted this content to a boyfriend/girlfriend.
- 21% of teen girls and 39% of teen boys say they have sent such content to someone they wanted to date
or hook up with.
- 15% of teens who have sent or posted nude/seminude images of themselves say they have done so to
someone they only knew online.
- 83% of young adult women and 75% of young adult men who have sent sexually suggestive content say
they have sent/posted such material to a boyfriend/ girlfriend.
- 21% of young adult women and 30% of young adult men who have sent/posted sexually suggestive
content have done so to someone they wanted to date or hook up with.
- 15% of young adult women and 23% of young adult men who have sent sexually suggestive material say
they have done so to someone they only knew online.
Addendum
- The Adam Walsh Act allows people as young as 14 on the National Sex Offender Registry; however,
the Act creates a “Romeo and Juliet” clause which excludes teens from the registry for consensual
sexual acts with individuals within 4 years of age of themselves. Not coincidently, states that have
passed the Walsh Act have failed to implement this aspect of the law
Note: Please check out these related sites--
|
| News report on a teen on the sex offender registry for "Sexting." <-------------------------------- |
| Teen listed as a "sexual predator/ Tier 3 offender" for consensual teen sex with other teens <-------------------------------- Original story here: http:// www.fox23.com/news/local/stor y/OK-Teens-Branded-Sex-Off enders/5hOYVYs2CEWr3AMO pVP5Uw.cspx |
| Copyright (c) 2007-2009 Derek "The Fallen One" Logue. All rights reserved. No part of this website may be used in any way without expressed written consent of the site owner. Once Fallen, "Through Wisdom and Knowledge Shall We Rise From The Ashes," Sex Offenders Pursuing Healing In Adversity (SOPHIA), and ReFORM Radio are all trademarks (TM) of Derek "The Fallen One" Logue. |
| DALLAS MORNING NEWS LIST OF OVER 4,000 TEXAS REGISTRANTS PLACED ON THE REGISTRY AS JUVENILES, SOME AS YOUNG AS AGE 10! http://www.dallasnews.com/database/2009/sexoffenders.html |
| GREAT VIDEO ON SEXTING BY TONIASFIGHT ON YOUTUBE! -------------------------------------> VISIT www.love-is-not-a-crime.com TODAY! |
| NEW! Awesome brochure on Teen Sex and the Law courtesy of www.rickyslife.com! CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD (reprinted here with permission) |
| ADDENDUM March 18, 2010 First US Court case to strike down prosecution threats over sexting laws. More specifically, the court ruled it is the discretion of the parents, not the courts, to educate teens involved in sexting incidents, and prosecutors cannot force sexting teens to take education classes under pain of felony charges. Miller v. Mitchell, No. 09-2144 [3rd Cir. 2010] http://www.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/092144p.pdf Georgia may allow Romeo and Juliet cases to petition to be removed from the public registry! Support GA HB-571! http://sexoffenderresearch.blogspot.com/2010/03/low-risk-sex-offenders-may-get-break.html |